Vera or Smartthings to start using Zwave controls

2015 · 3 replies · Configuration

This discussion is 11 years old. It predates today's Roomie Remote X, and the app names, menus, features, pricing, and device details below have changed substantially since 2015. Treat it as historical reference — see Support and current compatibility for how things work today.

In short

I'm new to Roomie want to add a Z-wave controller but I'm not sure if I should go with a Vera model or a Smartthings Sma — A member replied: “Can't comment on your other z-wave needs but you can probably control your Grafik-Eye thru Roomie. I have a Spacer system with remote 4 scene controls which I added to Roomie by running an emitter thru the wall and up to”

Question 2015-06 · older version

I'm new to Roomie want to add a Z-wave controller but I'm not sure if I should go with a Vera model or a Smartthings Smart Hub. I know that the Smartthings route requires the Roomie Agent but I'm fine with that. I'm just looking for the most reliable solution. The Vera looks good except I see so much complaining about the UI7 stuff. Is it really that bad? I want something at least fairly reliable (I know it won't be RadioRa2 reliable given it is a fraction of the price).

For some background, I'm starting by converting my home theater lighting from an old Grafik Eye (non-radioRa) to Zwave so I can add more zones and get better wireless control. I'd also like to add more Z-wave features around the house.

Thanks in advance for any advice.

Member 2015-06 · older version

Can't comment on your other z-wave needs but you can probably control your Grafik-Eye thru Roomie. I have a Spacer system with remote 4 scene controls which I added to Roomie by running an emitter thru the wall and up to the back of the remote switch. I know Roomie has a bunch of code sets for Grafik Eye.

Member 2015-06 · older version

You are right, I can control my Grafik Eye with Roomie but I want to switch away from Grafik Eye so I can add other Zwave integration in the house. Plus, I presently have 4 zones and want to add two more. That means redoing my Grafik Eye setup and it would be easier and cheaper to switch to individual Z-wave dimmers.

Member 2015-06 · older version

Have you looked into ISY? It is supported by Roomie and can control Zwave devices and, most importantly, it's extremely powerful. Bit of a learning curve though.

Related threads

Today's Roomie controls 400,000+ devices.

Roomie Remote X brings TVs, receivers, streamers, lights, and whole-home audio into one app on iPhone, iPad, Mac, and Apple TV.

Download Roomie Remote X